I don't remember exactly what my answer was at the time, but here are some better-thought-out ones:
A lot of our friends are also on small budgets.
The bartender? The grad student? The novelist? The one whose job you can't really describe, but it involves postmodernism? They're not rolling in cash. Unless you actually reach a point when all your friends are corporate lawyers, you probably won't be the only one living frugally.
A lot of our friends are a little weird, too.
We have a friend who commutes to work by unicycle. Another friend believes bacon is a health food and eats it in according quantities. Another friend is a professional blacksmith. Maybe it's just living in the neighborhood of Cambridge, MA, but there are a lot of eccentric people around. I don't mind being one of them.
You can have fun with your friends for cheap.
- A lot of our friends are from the folk dance scene. It doesn't cost much money, and participants tend to come from a wide variety of income levels. It's not that easy to pick out who's a psychiatrist and who's an art teacher.
- I enjoy cooking, so we often have people over for dinner rather than going to a restaurant.
- Jeff and two of his college roommates have a standard arrangement whenever their wives are out of town: the bachelor-for-a-day invites the others over, and they play board games their wives don't like.
Jeff works as a computer programmer, and in his thrift-store work clothes he actually looks less scruffy than most of his coworkers.
There are lots of metrics to compare people on.
I have a partner I love. My parents are alive and healthy. I have all my teeth. There are lots of ways you can compare yourself to other people — you'll come out ahead on some, and behind on some. That's true no matter your income.
Some of your friends will follow you.
We've heard friend say they admire us for following our principles. And some of them say they've changed because of us — looking for more effective charities, giving more, or asking people to donate instead of giving them birthday presents. I love hearing that.
We've met some awesome people through giving.
Since we started meeting other people who are interested in effective altruism, we've really clicked with some of them. After college I missed being able to talk ideas with people, and effective altruism has brought that back into my life. (The downside: you have to get over your stage fright about talking to people with impressive credentials. It turns out most of them are regular people.)